|
A recent
Institute of Civil
Engineers' (ICE) report suggests treated sewage effluent could
be a solution to the UK's
growing water shortage problems. Martin
Jolly, Technical Specialist at Earth Tech, a global provider of water and
wastewater treatment services, considers the environmental and economic issues associated
with this and other alternative methods of clean water generation.
Concerns about falling fresh water resources in Britain have
prompted water and wastewater companies to consider investing more in
sustainable technologies to help tackle future droughts and ensure reliable
supplies of good quality drinking water in the future.
Global warming, poor water management and the
public's nonchalant attitude to consumption are all blamed for growing fears
that the UK's
fresh water supply is drying up.
Previously, the answer might have been to build
more reservoirs, but hikes in land prices, particularly in areas of the country
most in need of extra resources, have put this option beyond the reach of most
commercial water companies.
Alternative methods of clean water production
are plentiful, but none is without financial, ethical or practical
limitations. The UK has learnt a great deal from
countries where swelling populations and drying climates are exacerbating the
problem of falling water supplies.
British engineers are closely involved in the development of new water
treatment technologies overseas and closer to home where trials of these methods
are taking shape.
Recycling
effluent
Recycling effluent is not a new concept in water
management. Water-scarce countries like Australia and Mexico are already using treated
sewage, mainly for irrigation. This is a
far less controversial and workable way to recycle wastewater.
In drought-hit Victoria, Australia,
Earth Tech has delivered the Campaspe Water Reclamation Scheme in a
public/private partnership with the local water authority. Launched in May 2005, the $30million scheme
is being used to treat 100% of the wastewater generated by a community in the
town of Echua
to supplement existing irrigation on privately owned farms.
Recycling effluent for human consumption means
overcoming major psychological and cultural barriers. The technology to do this already exists and
its effectiveness has been proven; convincing the public that it's a safe and
healthy option is a far more difficult task.
But treating wastewater to produce drinking water is by no means new to
the UK. In most areas of Britain, clean drinking water is
sourced from rivers into which treated effluent has been discharged from sewage
works. The process involves clarifying, filtering and disinfecting
sewage before the treated water is discharged into rivers to be extracted and treated again using normal
purification processes.
The ICE's proposals would effectively remove the
river stage of the process from the equation, in turn saving sewage and water
companies the cost of pumping and re-treating.
Treated sewage is usually crystal clear before being pumped into rivers
where it picks up mud and other sediments that add to the cost and time
involved in treating to domestic standards.
The new proposals would require major new water
treatment facilities to be built alongside sewage works. The cost of this is
proving a source of debate among water and sewage companies and public funding watchdogs. Hundreds of millions of pounds have already
been pumped into advanced treatment technologies for sewage works and treatment companies are understandably reluctant
to inject large amounts of extra capital into expensive drinking water
infrastructures.
Desalination
Significant funding is also being
invested globally in technologies such as desalination to treat sea water and
brackish water for domestic and industrial use.
Desalination plants are widespread in places
such as The Canary Islands, Israel
and Saudi Arabia; Florida and California
are also venturing down these roads.
Desalination is probably the most viable large
scale alternative to effluent reuse in the UK.
The process uses reverse osmosis to draw salt from seas and estuaries,
leaving clean water fit for drinking. It
works by pushing salt water through a series of ultra-fine membranes which
filter out the sodium and chloride ions.
However, desalination does have considerable
economic and environmental drawbacks. The
process consumes a lot of energy, creating greenhouse gases which could
exacerbate the problem of climate change and drought. One solution would be to employ energy recovery,
which means designing the plant to produce its own power by converting energy created
in the desalination process. In one
example of environmentally-friendly design, Perth, Australia,
has just completed a desalination project powered by greenhouse neutral energy
from a wind farm constructed close to the plant
Another concern is the potential for desalination
plants to disrupt seawater habitats and cause pollution from the high salt
levels in the wastewater pumped back out to sea. The environmental impact of constructing
major plants like these also have to be taken into consideration, particularly
if long pipes are needed to pump seawater into the plant and to distribute
treated water.
Conservation
Using tighter measures to conserve the UK's
natural water resources must be the priority for the water industry and
government. Calls for the widespread
introduction of domestic water meters and repair and replacement works to
leaking pipe networks are expected to gather pace in the coming months as the Environment
Agency and OFFWAT prepare to clamp down on water wastage in line with the
industry's next five-year performance plan which come into force in 2010. These measures must go hand in hand with
emerging technologies like effluent conversion and desalination if the water
industry is to improve efficiency and stand up to public scrutiny.
www.earthtech.com
Earth Tech is a global
provider of a full suite of engineering, construction and operations services to
the international water/wastewater, environmental, transportation, and
facilities markets. A business unit of Tyco International Ltd. and part
of the company's Engineered Products & Services segment, Earth Tech employs
some 8,000 talented people in more than 130 offices in 15 countries.
Founded in 1970, Earth Tech is headquartered in Long Beach, Calif.
More information on Earth Tech can be found at www.earthtech.com.
|